Do we need a neutral guild?

Guild is a better way to play the game cuz its funnier to play with friends or guild members. But I think we should have a neutral guild which allows every player to join it (dark, light ,neutral rep). The guild wont have some sort of guild quest or guild battle cuz the main reasons for this guild is helping the newbies that are under lv 40 (open test cap) and sharing the tips to each other. And when you reach lv 41, you can leave the guild or become a guider for newbies. (forgive me if there are english mistakes)

Neutral guilds would be nice, perhaps kicking you if your reputation swings too far in a direction.

Its pretty hard to stay in the neutral range, especially with quests giving you good rep or bad rep. Just don’t think the game supports neutral rep as of right now but it would be nice for those types of players

I think its quite late but the neutral guild is just used for some different reasons from the dark and light guild. For example: a guide guild will help newbies like above, a collector guild will collect all the variations of all items and an experiment guide will do some unique things like testing clash or the item stats. So the rep isn’t needed for these types of guild.

I mean to be fair if you created a neutral guild the quests given to that guild’s quest board could give no rep in either direction. Just a thought…

Typically, guilds that serve a utility purpose are light guild, because they are positive rep.

I know that , but this is a neutral guild and you can still join another guild if you want cuz its neutral. They look like the profession in some mmo game, make the game become funnier. In short, these neutral guilds are just like a guild to rest and enjoy the game.

I mean that would be cool, but just a big pain.
You would need to always jump from bad and good quests instead of focusing on one type.

No, the rep doesnt affect much on these guild. Like I said, these guild will only focus on doing some fun things and you dont need to be good or bad to join. You can still be a bad guy and see a member who is a good guy. This is neutral you know.

Now that I think about it, neutral guild would be able to receive both quest types, which might be a bit unfair.

I thought I have talked about the quest. These guilds cant do some normal things like quest or battles between guilds but they can do some different things like guide or experiment. “The guild wont have some sort of guild quest or guild battle …”

so just a stepping stone for new players? it sounds cool but i’m not really sure if it’d have a niche since several light/dark guilds already pledged themselves to helping new players who are unfamiliar with the game

Yeah ,but the neutral guild can do more things like " a guide guild will help newbies like above, a collector guild will collect all the variations of all items and an experiment guild will do some unique things like testing clash or the item stats."

My guild is a Neutral guild, it’s my Arcane Reborn guild, which is now dead, and ready to be revived and prepared to guide newbies on how to play the game correctly.
Guild Recruiting is only for guilds which have side factions, Light or Dark. (Cerulean order/Crimson Legion).
Noble guild is a neutral guild, meaning that both sides can join.
Newbies are mostly kids, they won’t actually understand you, so you must let them find out themselves what they really want to.

I would really like a neutral rep guild to be a thing, allthough it wouldn’t have much room for error reputation wise :confused: