Currently, stats such as limb loss protection and Beast Defense are tied to what the player has equipped as Vanity, which I think is a design decision that is detrimental to the game. Instead, Beast Defense and Limb Protection should be made into true stats that show up on equipment.
Potential Benefits
- Players can keep the look they have for their characters: People want to use vanity items to look cool, but tying Beast Defense and Limb Protection into vanity gets in the way of this. If you want your character to wear a tropical shirt, you will either be at a disadvantage, or give up on wearing a tropical shirt. A player that initially used their vanity slots for vanity purposes will be disappointed when they find they have to make it look like they’re wearing a helmet or take extra damage.
- More consistent design: In all other cases, gameplay effects from equipment come from what is equipped for stats. This could potentially be confusing to new players that expect stats to show up on equipment and be applied in the same way as power, defense, etc.
- Lifting of vanity restrictions: The restrictions on things such as having only one pauldron or helmet equipped may be lifted if it was due to these vanity stats that the restriction was put in place.
- More depth in equipment decisions: Right now, these vanity stats are effectively a yes/no choice: Either your vanity item gives the benefit of beast defense/limb loss protection, or it does not. There is no interaction with the rest of your equipment. By switching these to equipment stats, it becomes part of the consideration for actual equipment. For example, you may want to create a set to maximize effective defense against beasts, or swap out your robes for armor that will protect your limbs.
- More variety in equipment stats: With these vanity stats being a part of the equipment’s stat line, this opens up the option that some otherwise similar/same items have different amounts of the former vanity stats. For example, would Skyhall armorsmiths make armor with high Beast Defense, seeing as they don’t have wild animals up there? I do not think so, so perhaps their armor would have less Beast Defense in favor of a bit more normal Defense.
- Expanded design space for niche stats: This is a bit beyond the scope of the suggestion, but I feel it is worthy of consideration: with these niche stats moved to equipment, this paves the way for further niche stats to be utilized. For example, what if the diving helmet provided a small amount of air capacity? What if the otherwise weak animal equipment drops provided beast offense, to incentivize a progression path of hunting more dangerous game? If this re-introduction of Beast Defense and Limb Protection proves palatable to the players, it could be worthwhile to explore other niche stats on equipment.
Addressing Potential Drawbacks
- Incongruity with visuals: With this new way of handling these stats, a player visually wearing armor may get shredded by beasts or have their arm torn off while a player visually wearing a tropical shirt would be fine. I think the benefits outweigh this drawback, and this is not the only case of visuals not matching performance: a player with armor vanity can move extremely fast, a player with wizard vanity can be a kick king, a player that looks like they just washed up on Dawn Island can turn an island into a crater.
- Balance: The other side of the variety in equipment stats coin is that items that would otherwise be equal become unequal, and inevitably one is more favored. As long as there’s some use case for the now different items, I think this is fine. With these stats being relatively niche (one only applying to a specific category of enemy, the other only on big hits), I expect their relative values to be low compared to the core stats. With these stats having a ceiling of how much use you can get from them, I don’t see them being a big balance issue.
- There are also potential issues that could arise on the development side of things such as changes to data and re-implementing such a feature, but I have no insight as to how things work behind the scenes so what I have to say may not be applicable.
When I lose a limb because I wanted a particular look for my character, it feels bad. Taking four times more damage or however much it is because I don’t look like I’m wearing a full suit of armor feels bad. I hope to see these vanity stats be changed to normal stats, so that I am not put at a disadvantage by using the vanity system for vanity.