I think someone just saw acid, went “hm neat, a liquid that burns, would be a very useful magic”
And then got a hecate shard and mutated their water magic into it, I think it just imitates “liquid that dissolves and melts” and isnt an actual acid
Chemistry nerd here, it’s neither of these and I can prove it
Acid magic has 3 notable attributes
It burns flesh
It loses in a clash against glass
It isn’t flammable
Nitric acid violates rule 1, and hydroflouric/chloric rule 2
The best one off the top of my head that fits all 3 is sulfuric, which fits nicely with vetexes limited understanding of chemistry
Insulted the glorious lead developer, ez ban
tell me deadass you know more than 5 acids
Hydrochloric, hypochlorate, chlorate, hydrofluoric, sulphate, sulphite, sulfide, phosphate, carbonate, methanoic, ethanoic, propanoic, buthanoic, penthanoic, hexanoic, heptanoic, octanoic…
Seethe and rage ![]()
These are ions that’s cheating
You can’t just name increasingly long carbon chain acids
And you’re badly overreacting at a joke, or baiting ![]()
Bold of you to assume I’ve felt an emotion since I joined the forums
We need piranha solution magic ![]()
I am low-key impressed
Hydrochloric, sulfuric, nitric, citric, malic, formic, lactic, acetic
does acid even exist lmao
Like how Ancient Lightning magic is not an ancient magic, nor is the lightning itself ancient, I’d believe it just has a slightly misleading name for what it really is. It may be more of a digestion magic, like how Ancient Lightning is more of a superpowered large electrical discharge.
And not one magic is chemically accurate. If you assume that Wood magic users actually grow trees with their magic, where are the leaves? Is it simply magic wintertime when the leaves all fall off, or is it just inaccurate?
Do you think the guy who invented Aether magic was worried about accurately portraying the Aether?
it could just be wood magic instead of tree magic
Well if there was tree magic to contrast wood magic, (cough cough growth magic), you’d expect wood magic to be planks or chips of wood, but we got just leafless tree tops.
y’know, because wood is a component of trees, like how Metal Magic isn’t always shaped like toolboxes just because toolboxes are usually metal.
i think wooden logs is a good shape for wood magic, that’s the default form people would find it in. it’s not like you find toolboxes naturally
Bad news about what substance digestion uses
fair, but it has more branches than logs, and fresh branches usually have leaves.
sherlock up in here
i’d say it’s mostly just trunk, it looks too thick for the branches that have leaves to me. either way i think it’s fine though, it makes sense for mages to make tree-like structures since that’s where wood is sourced from
2/10