also what you’re replying to here was in reference to sunken elements, another thing people don’t seem to want to have solely tied to fishing lol.
A Replacement for Legendary Scales
effort
4.444444444444445
18
quality
4.368421052631579
19
reasonability
4.571428571428571
21
firstly where are you getting a 6th and 7th tier of potion from
also this will make getting luck much more fun and not the most boring part of the entire game
In 300 hours of gameplay I collected entire 0 legendary scales
It’s a great reward for reaching the epicenter
You’re granted with a chance to get some free sunkens
I reckon they’ll still remain locked behind a cookie clicker 3 that you can play with friends to talk to lessen the pain, these are only a few items that are in the game so far, and follows the tradition of sunkens from all the way back in AA
to add another obtainment method would be a good idea, you can see legendary fish scales glow from ontop the ocean deep in the dark seas being more common the deeper you go, maybe legendary fish scales can drop from the SEA MONSTERS there even, dropped from massive fish that are now no more.
It’ll return closer to pre-darksea rarity, I think people are upset about that, I think adding more obtainment methods would be good for everyone, sunken elements can be found from chests too right? if not maybe make them obtainable from underwater chests then.
I like diving too so maybe with dark sea diving megastructures ( bring your diving set ups and potions ) will make such things easier, if its happening you can suggest it for the dark sea for the nimbus sea.
It’s a new item being suggested, at best it looks like it’d do good for a VI and VII whenever those get added
If you have to actively distract yourself from the game to enjoy the game then it isn’t a very good game.
nothing should require “lessening the pain”.
it’s a difficult grind for things, just like how boss farm is more fun with friends, fishing may need an overhaul honestly, I’m not sure anyone likes the clicking you have to do, fishing minigames would be fun yeah and i already suggested for luck to still affect golden fish rates idk why they’re gutting it this deep with it not even affecting golden rates…
because it was broken overpowered and would allow players to get like every single new boss drop within 10 minutes of finding each new boss.
did you mean for why the removal is even happening? i get why its for massive ( WHICH IS LIKE 90% OF THE FISH that are legendary with luck fishing ) but dont understand why golden
because all legendary fish gave legendary scales and that lead to absurd snowballing
regardless, the replacement I suggested here solves the entire issue on all sides.
1: Players are no longer unsatisfied needing to go out of their way to play a cookie clicker minigame to get important luck reagents.
2: Vetex no longer has to worry about luck looping into luck looping into luck looping into luck and trivializing the entire game.
it does, but it can bring more issues to the table, with the removal, he doesn’t have to worry about it looping anymore too, i’m trying to look at this from vetex perspective and it look like ???
Fishing is boring as hell, not fun, and going to be even more painful now that we cant get legendary scales from fishing with luck (admittedly, its reasonable but its still so frustrating that theres no compensation for the hours, for some even days, of fishing, and that were going to have to keep fishing.).
On the flipside, this would make finding luck 1. Not something so boring you could fall asleep to it, 2. Tied to a funner activity, and 3. You could use luck again in fishing for the people that like cooking and for people trying to get sunkens.
LOL i’ve been falling asleep to it
can’t we just make it so legendary scales makes luck potions fishing only?
and an other potion type for everything else?
some kind of fishing potion sounds nice and fortune for everything else
NOOOOO
in my opinion it should be like in uhh deep underwater structures so I don’t have to suffer dark sea 1 hour hell 
I completely agree, it’s always been weird to me how such an important potion is obtained through the laziest activity in game, it’d definitely fit better as a dark sea reagent
4 Likes
STAND PROUD YOU CAN COOK
2 Likes