AO hot takes (new)

calling the inclusion of the grey ones racist is a gargantuan stretch and i think anyone who agrees with that point needs to find a hobby

If you live in a place with a long history of discrimination and abuse towards natives, then no, it isn’t a stretch. Especially since it literally uses similar points and language :broken_heart:

Bro we do have a hobby.

It’s reading. Most readers will probably notice this kind of stuff way more than those who don’t or are not aware of these kinds of tropes. Same with the orientalism thing as well. When you read so much stuff you start to notice patterns in the ways people are depicted.

This is not to say that Vetex is racist, just that his writing comes across as: ignorant, poorly written, and defined with racist tropes.

are we forgetting that the grey ones arent the only tribal group in ao

the monoah tribe on shell island are very clearly not depicted in any stereotypical way, they arent insane and cannibalistic they are just normal people with a tribal culture, therefore vetex clearly does not believe all tribes are like that

and cannibalistic tribes DO or HAVE existed in real life

if all tribal cultures in ao were similar to the grey ones in how they are depicted then sure id maybe agree with you, but they arent

I’m not saying he believes tribal people are one way or another or that he is racist or whatever.

We’re saying that the depiction is poorly written and comes across as racist/biased. And the existence of another tribe that isn’t poorly depicted doesn’t make this one not.

For example: Like imagine if you were reading something with normal depictions. Then there is a character who is large, black, speaks broken english (Really just AAVE but author sees no difference in the 2), likes fried chicken, drinks koolaid, steals, etc.

(Extreme example I know)

Just because this fictional book had good representation doesn’t make this single instance not racist. I’ve read books just like what I’ve described but on a more realistic subtle level.

I can even make an equivalent example for any other race as well :sob:

A lot of those cannibalistic tribes are sensationalized to hell and back due to racism making them out to be worse than they actually are. A lot of them in actuality were ritualistic or for funerary reasons.

The Grey Ones literally have nothing else to them except just eating people and being boogeymen. Then again other groups in AO have nothing else to them as well so I’d say it’s just Vetex 1-dimensionally copying tropes without realizing the implications and that he also included a racist one.

Remember when Stocksounds said that the Monoah people are “ooga booga” or whatever? That’s basically how Vetex wrote the Grey ones :skull:

As I said before you should read through that part of the thread for more context. I can even start linking tropes. It’s just that common :wilted_flower:

they arent cannibalistic and insane just for the love of the game though, they have a disease that effects their mental state, before that they were probably just normal skyhall citizens

i wouldnt count them as a traditional indigenous tribe like youre thinking of, they are outcasts of a kingdom that live in a tribal like society because they literally do not know any better

also lowkey they only eat humans because im pretty sure there arent any other animals or sources of meat in the nimbus lands :sob:

yada yada i don’t care let’s just all be friends

we are all friends here, this is just a debate not an argument

i didn’t mean for it to be taken literally but thanks for saying we’re friends :+1:

We are already friends.

Ellis doesn’t know who I am…

nope there are actually plenty sources of birds there and fruit (a few npcs state this too)
so they dont have an actual justification for killing and eating children who probably arent really that nutrient efficient anyways
maybe they’re gourmets that’d be funny, like any form of reason for them eating humans would make the Grey Ones better than what they are currently

it isnt stated anywhere but the only thing i can assume of is that they kill humans for trespassing and burying human corpses is a waste when u can eat them but then why isnt the wilds blocked out?

yeah stratos apples are apparently only specifically from that island and each is enough to keep you fed for weeks

maybe they make humans into protein shakes for pre workout

but people taste better than key

Skyhall was cool for what it was, and looks visually stunning. I do wish Skyhall’s story was much longer. We’ll probably revisit it (hopefully) again in the future as the story continues. There’s like 0 reason to revisit it aside from charts. It makes me think if they originally had more planned for it, considering they made an exclusive currency

Magic roster is bloated, shallow, unbalanced and uninteresting.

Fighting styles are fundamentally at a disadvantage in a game that’s mostly focused on projectile based combat.

Weapons and Relics should have the same customization as Magics and Fighting Styles, there’s no reason they shouldn’t as all it does is limit their potential for no good reason.

Side quests should be actual storylines that branch off from the main story instead of being chores.

colder takes than the vacuum of space

actually a hot take aside from balance

honestly, one of the most valid hot takes i’ve seen

my hot take is that magic was only fun to use during WoM and got old afterwards, especially after metamancing

Wrong mage skin disease is stated to not make you blood thirsty or a cannibal so they do it for the love of the game

hot take: ao map needs more smol islands like goso jungle to make exploring and sailing funner (also consistency, why are there only small islands in the north bruh)

gets bigger and badder closer to mount othrys!!!