(Here’s my rant on why I rated them like so)
Here’s my personal list:
S:
Elm and Mango, best islands for treasure charts hands down. Bit on the rarer side, but offer easy digging and great views from their location. I will always do these charts when I get them.
A:
Akursius, Harvest, Thorins, Whitesummit, and Sandfall. Akursius is here for it’s highly sought after blasted modifier, being the only island we have so far that provides it. Harvest and Whitesummit I feel are the fairest charts you can get with straight forward instructions on where each spot is. Thorins and Sandfall are both relatively small islands with decent charts although Thorins can have some small parts you might miss.
B:
Limestone, Forest, Darkpine, Munera, Frostmill, Blasted Rock. Limestone and Forest have natural rival spawns above certain parts which can destroy your treasure part, forcing you to wait for it to respawn. Beware pvpers on Munera who will sometimes jump you while doing treasure charts, Darkpine is just kinda depressing ngl. Frostmill currently has a bug where it blinds you with the force of a thousand suns, in addition to every part above the village being treated as “on a high cliff”. Blasted rock is a long detour away from the center of the map, but is otherwise an easy chart with huge parts.
C:
Windrow, Ravenna, Goso. Windrow and Ravenna are both massively sprawling islands with plenty of parts that you can easily miss. Most of your charts will point to these two locations and honestly at this point I’m tired of doing them. I don’t like Goso jungle’s aesthetic ¯_(ツ)_/¯
F:
Aka fuck off tier, Palo and Shell. I HATE YOU. Palo Town has the single handly most condensed and populated treasure section of all the islands on the map, forcing you to spend hours digging to find the right part. Not to mention the sand spot only reachable by clipping into the ground on palo. Shell island will decieve you. This island has the most unclear instructions out of any we have seen. “Halfway” on this chart can range from a few feet off the center of the island to the very edge. The pillars are counted in the territory of shell island making distance very skewed. (Marking or Goldsight is required and recommended for these islands)
i use to hate wind row but now i can travel from island to island pretty fast and they have crystalline mod so for me ill bump it to A
ravenna
straight up useless i hate you superheated mod
blasted i never really tried cause its all just sand mod and its far as hell
Almost all of my scrolls I get is shell island, and its the few paces away variety to. I fucking hate those scrolls. More so than ravenna or wind-row ones.
Honestly ive been doing charts slot at the point i just now how charts work on every islands, shell was probably most difficult cuz all shell charts just “High cliff” meaning its just on the mountains of shell island
isn’t the blasted rock rival/criminal spawn literally on an area that isn’t even considered part of blasted rock (cassia bay) and like too far to actually destroy parts of blasted rock.