Change Clan rank permissions so that every rank has a use

Change Clan rank permissions so that every rank has a use
effort 4.0 1 quality 3.0 1 reasonability 4.5 2

Current Permissions

The current and planned permissions for every current clan rank are:

  • Leader: Full control, only rank that can withdraw from the clan bank
  • Co-Leader: Invite/Kick perms
  • Admin: Building perms
  • Elite: nothing
  • Member: Nothing

In this state, the elite rank has no use other than a form of status, and those permitted to invite people to the clan have to be promoted to Co-Leader, which is a rank that should really have more trust put into it.

Proposed New Permissions

All mentioned ranks will of course still have access to whatever power they already had.

  • Co-Leader: Bank withdrawal access, promotion of lower ranks up to admin
  • Admin: Invite Perms, Kick perms(debatable, but trust is important in the first place)
  • Elite: Building Perms

This makes Co-Leader permissions much more fitting of the name. When you make someone a Co-Leader of a group, you trust them with near full control. It shouldn’t be a role you want to give to anyone that you trust with simply invites/kicking. Admins should be that role.
On the topic of admins, there’s literally no reason they SHOULDN’T have at least invite permissions.
This change would also give elites a use.

Insurance measures

If this change is to take place, all members below Leader should be automatically demoted to member, so the leader can reorganize properly.

Additionally, there should be a help UI somewhere that informs the leader (and Co-Leaders with now given power to promote) of what permissions each rank gives a member.

1 Like

Alternatively, just have dynamic permissions so clans can set what ranks can do what.

11 Likes

Just being able to set permissions for each role would be infinitely better than any preset.
If I made a guild with my friends I’d want all of them to share as close to equal power to me and everyone else as possible.

1 Like

Equally, if you want fast expansion, inviting perms shouldn’t be locked at the same level people can do impactful things- like saving builds.

I love the suggestions that make clans more intuitive and easier to run, good suggestion.

Yes, dynamic permissions absolutely need to be implemented. The clan bank is basically useless without the clan leader for small friend-group clans (such as the one I’m in), and it would be great to have everyone able to do anything (such as editing description/image when that’s added) if the leader so desired.

This topic was automatically closed 24 hours after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.