Change dolomite into pumice

Change dolomite into pumice
effort 5.0 6 quality 4.833333333333333 6 reasonability 5.0 6

Introduction

I assume we’ve all seen dolomite in the game by now. It’s a small grayish rock, which is naturally found floating on the surface of the sea after an undersea volcano eruption, and is used in making orbshots.

There’s one slight issue.

THIS ISN’T REALISTIC AT ALL!!!

In real life, dolomite is a sedimentary rock. This means it’s formed via various different particles settling underground in layers, with dolomite itself consisting in great part out of fossilized shells of ancient sea creatures. This creates a small problem.

You are never going to find dolomite near any kind of volcano.

See, volcanos, wildly enough, create volcanic, or magmatic rocks, such as basalt and obsidian. These rocks were formed out of cooling magma and lava, not out of layers of various particles. This makes it extremely unrealistic that you’d find dolomite near an eruption site.

Second, bigger issue: DOLOMITE DOESN’T FLOAT ON WATER.

At a density of 2.84g/cm^3, dolomite is nearly three times more dense than water, which means it sinks in it like, shockingly, a rock. Thus, even if an event did happen that’d shoot out hundreds of small dolomite fragments, if you search the surface of the sea to find them, you will be looking for a very long time.

If only there were a rock that was both formed in and near volcanos, that could also float on water…

Introducing: pumice

Pumice is a type of rock that, in short, forms after pressurized magma is ejected out of a volcano. The rapid depressurization causes bubbles of trapped gasses to expand, while the cooling hardens the lava, traping the gasses inside. The result is a highly porous rock.

Pumice is a rock tightly bound to volcanic activity, and obviously forms as a result of eruptions, unlike the sedimentary dolomite. However, its high porosity bears another characteristic:

Pumice is one of the few rocks that can float on water.

This makes pumice the ideal solution to our issue. It only forms in large quantities as a result of an eruption, and also floats on water. Thus, if you went looking for dolomite on the surface of the sea above undersea volcanos, you’d be looking for a while, but if you went looking for pumice, you’re far more likely to walk away with full hands.

This change is very simple, would take just some slight renaming, yet would solve several terrible issues:

  • It stops spreading misinformation that dolomite, a sedimentary rock, is commonly found near volcanos, and can float on the water
  • It makes Arcane Odyssey more educational by teaching kids how pumice is made and what special properties it has
  • It gives Vetex a scholarly reputation
  • And most important of all, it’s far more realistic
9 Likes

I love this. I dont understand the topic but I know its good.

Anyway what did orbshot do? I have one cuz I buy it from auction. I thought it was some kind of potion although I buy it from ammo category.

i won’t fact-check this and will blindly trust the logic out of laziness

Cannonball that inflicts status effect

We could go as far as to say it’s more realistic because you’re filling the hollow pumice up with potion…

Suit yourself, I’ve based this mostly off previous knowledge and some quick searches, but unless wikipedia and google lied big time, pumice is indeed a rock which floats on water, which is how it got name in my language

Correct!

This whole time I’ve been swimming down to the ocean floor only to find nothing cause I thought dolomite spawned underwater…

geniunely satisfying to see someone knowing physics instead of pulling out utter bullshit out of their asses

Huh, just as I wws getting into listening to a geologist talk about the geographic makeup of Minecraft, Vintage Stor, and Hytale…

Anyways, I applaud your devotion.

When the game that tries to be realistic fails to be realistic for the dumbest reasons:

Also I think Vetex likes to put random shit together without thinking about it much, like the one time Karate was a fighting style idea on the trello and it would’ve been themed around grabs, which I not only think wouldn’t work gameplay-wise but they’re also restricted/banned in Karate and it’s not something normally-associated with the style.

Now just where did you get that from? That has never happened!

Pushes all the times it happened behind curtain

behind a curtain? that’s a bit of an ineffective way to hide them considering how many instances there are

take my vote btw

uhhh No but I agree dolomite Floating on Water is Stupid

Shush it’s for realism

i have never seen dolomite neither i care enough but sure :smiley: .

This topic was automatically closed 3 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.