Changes to PVP as a PVE player (since most of these PVPers can't make a good suggestion)

Changes to PVP as a PVE player (since most of these PVPers can't make a good suggestion)
effort 4.5 10 quality 3.909090909090909 11 reasonability 3.5 12

The split between PVE and PVP has caused a massive rift in the community and completely killed the PVP side. While this isn’t inherently a bad split, nor will this suggestion seek to combine both back into the same experience, I do agree that PVP needs some changes to be more rewarding. Unfortunately, most PVPers cannot make a good suggestion without insulting people, displaying large amounts of arrogance, not listening to feedback, or just having poor ideas in the first place, so I will be doing their jobs for them.

The Issue-

As PVP stands currently (at least from what I’ve been hearing from PVPers), the entire system is just dead. Nobody plays Arena, nobody fights in clan servers, and places like Elysium are often boring due to lack of terrain, thus causing builds that prioritize landing large amounts of damage to shine over ones that would otherwise be good for overworld ganking, killing build diversity and also enjoyment.

To summarize these points, I will put them in a generalized list-

  1. Lack of build diversity
  2. Lack of player interaction
  3. Lack of rewards

Rewards

This is the easiest part to remedy and thus I will be tackling it first.

Add more rewards to existing PVP mechanics, these include but are not limited to-
Clan Wars, Arena, Bounty Hunting and Island Claiming

Clan Wars - Every participating member of the winning clan receives loot equivalent to 20 rare, higher tier clans could potentially get more rewards like Acrimonies, Lost Knowledge, High-Tier Imbued Gear, or Sunkens if seen fit. These should be large scale heavily rewarded but high risk battles. (Added in post-suggestion) - These would be distributed to individual clanmates based on their performance, not universally given to every member in the server. As long as you got 1 kill (i.e your participation reward), you will be rewarded in some fashion, though the higher tier stuff will need certain amounts of performance to acquire.

Arena - Winning a fight gives 1-2 Rare Chests worth of loot. Any sort of high-ranking placement (top 100/50/25/10/5/3/1) will give progressively more rewards, up to things like Lost Knowledge or potentially Sunkens. Rankings will reset monthly (if they don’t already). There would also be exclusive color-changing titles based on Arena ranking. Inspired by chime of conflict in Deepwoken except with better equivalent rewards for doing well that month.

Bounty Hunting - The most important PVP mechanic since its the generic overworld hunting which is most PVPers favorite place to PVP. I’m not sure what exactly to reward it with so I’m just going to copy what Deepwoken’s voidwalker origin does. So when you finish a bounty (either hunting them or reverse hunting someone hunting you), a large chest will pop up with an exclusive lootpool. Would give a bit of mid-tier loot with lower chances of getting high tier stuff[1] similar to getting things like relics from bounties in Deepwoken.

Island Claiming - A more fleshed out island building feature with better rewards (like more reagent pots and other things like it), in addition to that, they could also passively get random low-tier rewards for having an island claimed under the pretense of harvesting the Island’s Resources. This could potentially vary between islands for more conflict over said resources. (Stuff like islands with higher altitude getting reagents like copper shrooms passively, more temperate island giving a large amount of food such as wheat/fruit, rockier islands giving stuff like gems, etc). Islands will no longer give nor take infamy for claiming them, and instead act simply as outposts for the clan to act out of with the other rewards mentioned previously. Conflict now, instead of stemming from losses and gains of infamy, will be incentivized by resource gain. If you want a bunch of copper shrooms then you have to go raid the base at shale reef where you get them passively in high amounts.

Exclusive Rewards-

Any exclusive rewards that I haven’t already mentioned (like arena titles) can be added in whatever capacity the Developers/Balance Team deems worthy. These can be stuff like Titles, Vouchers (not for gamepasses but for other obtainable ingame items), etc.

Lack Of Build Diversity

This is mostly in response to things like Elysium where it’s just a big empty arena, leading to builds that stack defense and power excelling.

While this isn’t a complete solution to the issue, here are some ideas to fix it-

  1. Since Elysium is like this heavenly place where warriors spend their days, give it the ability to mimic certain terrain/ingame locations to a degree to simulate overworld encounters while in Elysium. Not sure how to implement this but the easiest way I see is having the server owner being able to change the primary arena to do this. There could also be options for somewhat randomized terrain, or options for pre-set options/terrain.
  2. Hopefully the addition of terrain to this system would help remedy the strength of primary stat-stacking builds as they’ll struggle with corners/walls, but in case the owner does not want to change the arena, the outside of the main arena could have smaller “dueling platforms” that are controlled by the 2 players that occupy them. This would be less invasive as there are usually multiple fights going on in the main arena so a terrain change may not be wanted by everyone in that area.
  3. For Arena, there could be a system that gives buffs and nerfs to certain aspects of your build, similar to vows in JJS ranked, and these could be formatted as temporary blessings from gods. These can include things like 25% more damage but 3-5 drawback for example. There would be 3 options randomly selected from a big list then you pick 1 of the options.
  4. Bit iffy about this one so I’ll determine based on feedback, but pre-set builds applied to both players in the arena (either a selection of pre-set options or a standard option like having no stats at all, fighting with just your own skills rather than your accessories for honor or something). This technically kills build diversity since builds wont be needed but I feel like it is a needed addition considering the state of Arena builds. Could also possibly be added to Elysium as a toggleable option too.

I’m not sure what else to do other than this, if anyone has more ideas feel free to add, build diversity is a big issue and cannot be solved through purely pvp mechanics (an overall general method would be giving some sets unique innate buffs to allow for more niches, but it’s only a matter of time until a definitive meta minmaxed set shines for each playstyle after that)

Lack Of Player Interaction (+New Features)

I already tackled a bit of this in the other parts, primarily in rewards, as more rewards will incentivize people to return and new players to get into it, but here’s a new feature for more interaction (credit to @Awesome_Wafflez for coming up with this idea in response to a different PVP suggestion)-

Tournaments

Every 90-120 minutes of real-world time, a Tournament will be hosted in clan servers taking place at the server’s sea’s arena island (Munera/Isle of Ash currently)

These would work how you expect, people go to the island and register to the tournament and they are put into duels against other players until there’s 1 final player standing. Players will be given a 10 minute heads-up, and once those 10 minutes are up all registrants are teleported to an instanced arena which will be a larger version of the arena island (since islands are shrunk down for gameplay purposes)

Before the matches begin, all registrants will vote on the rules of the tournament. This includes stuff like arena maps (how the arena will be created), bracket ruling (rules like second chance which will have more overall rewards but defeated players get 1 more chance to return to the tournament, or a free for all rule) and how they want match-ups to be set up (randomly, renown based, infamy based, etc).

When you’re defeated you can either return to lobby, spectate, or get put into a “gulag”-esque match if the second chance rule was voted to be enabled.

Rewards would be given as seen fit for this PVP “world event”, I’ve already given examples of what rewards could be in the other features but this would be a decent bit more rewarding than arena matches but less rewarding than clan wars since there is no risk in participating. All participants will get a reward but placing higher gives better rewards, and rewards are given when the player is defeated for good (once normally, twice for second chance ruling).

The above example has 1 flaw which was brought up, and that was that some PVPers want full-server overworld mechanics, so that’s what this next feature will be.

“War Mode“ (totally not a copy of deepwoken heh!)

When there are 3+ different clans in a Clan Server, they can start War Mode via a vote between clans (accessible in clan menu). This would be a high stakes server-wide event where defeating someone grants a good bit of rewards. Different milestones of defeating certain amounts of people will grant special chests with better loot pools and the winning clan will get a lot of rewards. This would only be able to be done once per day and the event lasts for an hour after the initial voting goes through. The server UI will be reddish/orange and a UI at the top will show the current top clans in PKs in the server. A War Mode server will also have a red name/outline in the server menu so you can easily find them. Joining a War Mode server in a clan that did not vote on it will cause you to get halved rewards but this will not put your clan’s personal vote on the cooldown for the day.

In additional to these 2 mechanics but not a big enough suggestion to warrant its own drop-down, just increase clan server player counts so there are more people active at once and thus more chances to encounter someone.

That’s it for this suggestion, if anyone has ideas or concerns then reply with them and I’ll consider editing the suggestion to acknowledge them if I or a lot of other people deem it is a good addition.


  1. Things I’ve already mentioned- LK, Sunkens, Acrimony, just overall highly sought after/coveted items ↩︎

4 Likes

At first, I was actually going to roast this suggestion; however, seeing that you have provided a genuine recommendation with some effort, I will show some humility and give my humble feedback.

Why do I feel as though it’s about a specific person :thinking:

Rewards

I have no problems with the possible rewards that can be provided to PvPers based on their effort. There are many obvious problems, such as the lack of rewards in the arena, Elysium, and the leaderboard, and as a result, the game fails to keep players hooked. So your solutions actually present an admirable approach to addressing this issue.

That said, they will only appeal to a newer playerbase that hasn’t learned the P of PvP yet. We, the older generation, feel no satisfaction, joy, or pleasure at all from getting some measly rewards, as most of us are also very good PvErs and controlled large chunks of the market, at least while it was active. Personally, I had hundreds of millions of galleons worth of inventory, with close to 1000 sunken and many acrimonies before the wipe and the change to the luck system. We do PvP for the competition and to chill while flexing our skills against not-so-skilled players, and the latter only worked when there wasn’t any toggle.

So, in TLDR, those reward changes will not keep or bring back the old playerbase, although they will certainly be good for newer ones, if that is even possible with how Roblox is nowadays.

Another thing to mention is that AO will never flourish without mobile support, but that’s for another discussion.

This is wrong; this used to be the case before, sure, but nowadays, you can only PvP with the same people. And if you are someone like me with over 30k kills, most PvPers won’t even duel with you after one round. In addition to that, Elysium never captures the same feeling of PvPing as back in the old days in Munera or Sameria, again due to the toggle.

This is a nice idea I would love to see in the game.

I also liked the Tournament system and war modes, but I can tell you from experience that war modes will not work the way you might think. First of all, you can never assume someone in a clan will stay alone and won’t pull up with 10 other clanmates. Most clan wars generally go pretty one-sided, as each big clan has a unit of pure AOE dealers ready to engage when notified. The side that gets the first few kills generally ends up winning, and the fights then go on for a couple of hours, depending on the strength of both sides.

War mode is also terrible news for top leaderboarders, as when their location gets exposed, their death is almost guaranteed.

Overall, I liked most of your ideas, and it would be great if they could be accommodated into AO. However, most of your ideas look good only on paper. When you consider the psychology of a PvP player, you realize they won’t change much. The problem with PvP is not that there aren’t enough incentives; it’s that you can’t hunt people freely, which takes away from immersion.

1 Like

This is kinda basic

There weren’t a need ever for more PvP incentives in a game with a primary focus on PvE, PvP was only ever considered as to not fall under an arbitrary CCU.

If you wish to be rewarded for PvPing, go hunt players for bounties.

erm.. I think the reward for pvp is actually that it’s just fun to do!
mobile support?? yeah if you want to melt a bunch of phones I guess you could add it (if you cover the entire screen in buttons of course)

oh yeah they’re just miserable all the time and hate everything always


why did the reply not work??

Is the reward for pve also just that its fun to do?

Sometimes I wonder if pve players engage their pre frontal cortex when typing

:x:
The soon-to-be update will introduce a metric ton of optimizations and the glory StreamingEnabled is!

Phones will be able to handle Arcane Odyssey if it received mobile support, of course it’d take more to run it, but it would run!


dopamine

it’s supposed to be
in practice, not really

I’m so sorry…

Dap
You aight…

Anyway the suggestion is aight but misses the mark imo

Fairly decent ideas, though I’m a bit concerned they won’t really be enough—most players get into PVP when they’ve nearly exhausted all of the game’s PVE content, and at this point, I have to ask whether just giving them standard loot will mean anything to them. After all, 90% of chests don’t mean anything to PVE players, either, and they’re not usually as capped out as PVP players.

Skull reactions is like a cheese for those rats.
I agree with what you said in introduction.

Turning on PVP gives you absolutely NOTHING. It’s a toggle completely for your personal playstyle and preference. Yet, some people try to force it in suggestions, without properly hearing out PVE players, not caring about them, and instead focusing on themselves (that’s okay to do, but not when you’re literally suggesting to change the whole gameplay of the game).

Now what I’d like to say about your suggestion:

Rewards - they could depend on clans’ reputation, the more reputation, the more to fight for, however I would NOT give clans acrimonies, that would downgrade its already downgraded price.

I stand for Acrimony’s original value being at One Million Drachma.
Couldn’t care less about sunken.. Got bunch of it…

Just saying that clans would have receive acrimonies already makes me think that every member will receive one, and if so - imagine if people do that intentionally to start farming?
Your over-all suggestion ruins the balance and definition of rarities and values of such items, I disagree with this scale of rewards, although I have no proper idea what to suggest instead of what you mentioned, however, I have one remark which could make your suggestion better:

  • Add kill counter, aka contribution in the clan war.
    Max contribution would be 50% or so, and minimum would be 25%
    That way I think everyone remains fairly awarded, however, I’d like to mention that people who have just 1 or 0 kills, wouldn’t be awarded at all, but basically depending on amount of members of clan who participate in clan war. Feel free to take notes and polish this idea of mine.

I like your idea about Elysium’s terrain, despite I’ve never been here, but idea of being able to change its terrain is a good feature. Personally I see it as place for trainings/duels, and it fits, pretty sure you think tho as well.

That’s probably all I have to say.

  • I like the core of your suggestion..But I’m not sure if that’s a good idea though, like yea making PVP actually reward you is good, but then on the other side.. I’m not sure if that keeps the PVP and PVE on the same weights, if you know what I mean, not sure I phrased that understandingly or correctly.
1 Like

not anyone in specific, it just happens that a certain demographic of PVPers have the exact same mannerisms and issues

i have no issue with that minion guy who made actual good reasons for why some parts needed changes in that one suggestion, it simply makes sense and there should be risk in the risk part of the game, just what is risk without reward

well that seems to be what some people wanted as mentioned in the “pve incentives for pvp” which you seemed to love, and generally skill in pve doesn’t matter too much as most rare things are locked behind time consuming tasks rather than difficulty tasks (pve is way too easy), which would bar a slight minority of casual pvpers from obtaining these items if they don’t want to go through the pain of rolling RNG after RNG for lost charts then spending an hour after all of that to complete it

like i said above i feel like some players may return (especially if they’re casual pvpers and couldn’t care to dump hours into farming for LK), but overall more people interacting with it for the new rewards is good for everyone engaging with it

what part of it is wrong? i was talking about the feature in a vacuum, not current elysium, just giving some solutions to issues that were brought up (like it being a open arena causing build diversity to be bad, thus giving it the ability to mimic terrain which should be possibly given its basically heaven, would allow some people to simulate overworld easier or something)

hmm maybe a cap of a certain # of clan mates in the server? like maybe 3-5 per clan then no one else can join until the event is over?

they could leave if they don’t want to participate, nothing stopping them from doing so just like deepwoken’s war mode, it wouldn’t like perm combat tag everyone

but this does bring up another issue of someone leaving whenever people get close and rejoining afterwards, so maybe kills will reset if you leave even if other clanmates are in the server (just your individual kills, not the entire clans)

i understand that, but what i guess im trying to accomplish is to make it so clan servers is a place where you can hunt freely by introducing more people and making interactions happen more frequently (like with the server player cap increase)

i appreciate the feedback, ill see what you think of the other things i brought up in this reply

yeah actually i quite enjoy diving and sometimes doing charts/forts

interesting, what about the issue of a bajillion buttons? not that that really stops mobile players, those mfs are built different

That however is something the game has to be designed around to support, you can have all of said buttons but at some point it’d just not be worth it, as with one magic alone you can have more buttons than most other games on Roblox.

Though as you say:

It may be possible, but it certainly won’t reach the greater majority of mobile players as the aforementioned “built different” players are commonly competitive compared to the usual of kids on their parent’s phone playing roblox (and spending thousands of dollars on R$).

Possible, but not worth it.

i disagree, you already get a guaranteed acrimony from legendary chests which also give 100k drachma, why would you need 10 a legendary chests amount in drachma to be able to purchase a single acrimony? all prices in the AH should fall since the only way to get into making that sort of money is often times through auctioning your own stuff rather than being able to interact with games systems to be able to afford them, 1 million is not feasible to acquire without trading with other players, but finding a legendary chest is very much feasible as long as you’re somewhat lucky

maybe just the top contributor of the clan war then, because i do agree that having 20 people gain an acrimony for a task that takes an hour most is bit too extreme, so ill go fix that

already mentioned this but it’d be visual for the entire clan, guess ill add some way to see individual kill counters in the server (maybe just in the same ui but a click)

maybe 0 kills but i think if you helped your clan in any way you should be rewarded, even if only slightly

rewards can scale up like i mentioned though

PVPers enjoy the intensity of fight so rewarding them for high risk high reward scenarios is natural, whereas us PVE-ers can acquire the same things but would take longer due to the security of not being bothered during them, i think that isn’t too bad of a design philosophy

this may be personal reasoning for them but i think that certain aspects (such as arena putting everyone on an equal playing field with having pre-set or no gear at all) would help some PVPers build up skill and also resources so that they can venture into other parts without needing to do the PVE aspect that they may not enjoy (diving/charting isnt for everyone)

I will reply to it when I have some time :+1:

Overall I agree with this take. I just have a couple things to say/ask.

PvPers back in Empires did care about claimed islands, as it was a passive way to gain infamy and funds for clans holding them (With planted reagents passively harvested for connected clan members as well. This is still a thing too.) and a potential massive infamy gain for attackers if the claim was abolished. Claimed islands also made for excellent double-sided bait as your target would likely come to your island to bait you, or you could use it to bait them into coming over.

Just out of curiosity, what exactly would be your proposed rate for a chance to get higher tier items?