Community made anime tier list

Groundrules:

  1. Only the anime adaptation will be counted, the source material will not. If we did it based on the manga, lots of things will be shifted (for example, One Piece being bumped up to S tier and Demon Slayer being bumped down to B tier)
  2. The fandom will be ignored because most animes here would be dropped down to F tier if it was.

that’s basically it let’s go

SSSSS: Kirby Right Back At Ya

  • Kirby Right Back At Ya: i will personally send you to the corner if you object

S: Hajime no Ippo

  • Hajime no Ippo: A perfect entry-level anime with fantastic animations, great themes, very interesting story and characters, comedy bits are actual GOLD, SFX and OST are top notch. There are very few to no faults with this anime and is overall, just fantastic.

A: One Piece, JoJo’s Bizarre Adventure, Demon Slayer, DBZ, Rurouni Kenshin

  • One Piece: VERY interesting story with some great drama, great comedy, god tier payoffs (oda plans things YEARS in advance), etc. Would easily be an S tier if the anime wasn’t riddled with a shit ton of filler to artificially slow down the pacing so it doesn’t catch up to the manga.
  • JJBA: pretty good i guess
  • Demon Slayer: Pretty good in terms of actual story, but the story alone would be at a lower tier. However, elevated to a whole new level due to the animation being exceptional.
  • DBZ: Very good but has a few flaws keeping it from S tier (i.e inconsistent power scaling).
  • Rurouni Kenshin: Great anime with strong and deep themes. Story is A tier during its beginning, S tier during Kyoto arc (absolutely fantastic), but is brought down by the third act (all of it is filler since the mangaka was writing the Jinchuu arc, so it couldn’t be animated)

B: DB Super, Overlord

  • DB Super: Pretty good, but has even more flaws than DBZ to warrant A tier (i.e Jiren).
  • Overlord: Overpowered protagonist but actually done right. Pretty good worldbuilding (not top tier like One Piece, but still very good) too.

C: idk

D: idk

F: SAO

  • SAO: Do I have to explain this?
2 Likes

jojo - a tier

idk its the only anime i’ve watched in the past year

jojo is either a tier or s tier
great anime in general

your tier list is good, sao is doo-doo

Kaguya-sama: Love Is War is X tier (higher than S)

*Takes down before destroyed below

I’ve got a lot but writing it all would cause some sort of confusion in the title and im kinda lazy to get all of the anime’s picture cover to place them all in the rank.

Ikr

1 Like

Demon Slayer: A
Ok story boosted by exceptional animations.

would demon slayer be B or C tier w/o animations included
i’m still doing A tier for it

Dragon Ball Z/Super - B tier

Alright story with a widely known protagonist. However, the power scaling is inconsistent.

i’m a db stan but it’s got its issues man.

super is B tier (never watched it, but i’ve heard it has a few big flaws), never watched Z but i’ve heard it’s very good
based on what i heard, super B tier Z A tier
wat u think

2 Likes

y e :+1:

Overlord

B-A tier bcs who doesn’t like a big ass ruler of everything as an MC :fr:

ok my opinion
rurouni kenshin/samurai X A tier
would be S tier if not for post-kyoto arc being filler (jinchuu act was still being written, couldn’t be animated)

Rurouni Kenshin
  • sure i agree, put it on tierlist
    • no i think it’s higher/lower
    • haven’t watched it

0 voters

rurouni kenshin/samurai X: trust and betrayal S tier
one of, if not, the BEST OVAs EVER. very deep themes, pristine sound effects, great OST, awesome animation. very little to no flaws

Rurouni Kenshin: Trust and Betrayal
  • sure i agree, put it on tierlist
    • no i think it’s lower
    • haven’t watched it

0 voters

opinion round #2, Hajime no Ippo S tier, OPM (S1) either A or S tier
HNI: great animations, great themes, very interesting story, comedy bits are GOLD, soundtrack/SFX are great, etc.

Hajime no Ippo
  • sure i agree, put it on there
  • lower
  • haven’t watched

0 voters

OPM: same reasons as demon slayer but story is more engaging/interesting. great story, god tier animation (madhouse did a FANTASTIC job with the fights)

OPM
  • S
  • A
  • haven’t watched

0 voters

I read the manga and the story is alright rlly. Would be B~C tier without animations.

Darling in the FranXX A tier, It was great but the ending sorta killed the mood :sob:

mob psycho 100 is really good, probably one of the best shows i’ve seen.

SS+ tier

Full metal alchemist brotherhood

Accurate to the manga.
Great story with no filler.
Well written characters.
Definitely worth watching.

S tier at least