Grand Navy? What’s so grand about 'em.
self-proclaimed “peacekeepers” (totally not just guarding their colonies and trade routes)
I dislike the idea of one big company fighting the criminality. They are easy to get corrupted.
Okay hang on you asking if their existence makes sense writing wise or like from an in universe should an organization like that exist?
every major vetex game needs a powerful lawful good organisation that spans all the seas/ continent so yeah id say it fits
I’d much prefer it if every kingdom dynamically protected themselves from specific threats, rather than just leaving it to the One Piece people.
i mean even in something like one piece there are islands that dont rely entirely on the marines
in ao ravenna centurions do protect the island, they cuffed ruby roger in sailors lodge, and they have the camp on shell island, they dont just wait for the navy to show up whenever theres a criminal they just deal with their own problems while the navy is more focused on issuing bounties to big criminals and fighting piracy
im not saying its realistic im just saying kingdoms do protect themselves, they dont wait on the navy lile youre saying
They let the Navy deal with piracy and criminals, while their legally blind troops ignore the known threat to the safety of the entire kingdom in an assassin’s creed cosplay.
both
I mean in the narrative perspective it makes sense. I understand from Vetex’s statements and whats said in game how it came to be and what role it serves. Based on already past events that have happened in the story as well as what Vetex has said about future appearances it does seem like they will have a role in the main story. Even then they don’t really need to as they can just exist as an interesting part of the world building that’s involved with a lot of side content both with players joining the gn and future side bosses like Mizeria.
In universe I honestly don’t know what I would think. Irl I think an organization like that which can interfere with other nations and holds what seems to hold a lot of power over other nations and can do basically whatever and leaving no room for protest, would be a bad thing. It’s like a UN except instead of being made up of a bunch of nations all over the world that try to work together to keep things chill globally it’s just one country that’s making the calls. After the initial treat signing it’s basically entirely up to the GN for what it does.
However if I was someone in universe I don’t know if I would think that way. Pirates are a massive problem in the War Seas and it seems like the GN are the only ones who can effectively handle them. A lot of the other kingdoms are tied up in the near constant conflict between each other. I think as civilian in that world I would be more scared of pirates or genocidal rulers with nuke powers than I would of the GN having too much power. I’d probably feel like the GN was basically a necessity to the survival of basically any town that isn’t very important to the kingdom it belongs to.
1 Like
I like to imagine that they just pull up at Caitara whenever they need to execute somebody from Shieldguard.
They don’t get permission or anything, they just kill somebody out there before the guards can show up.
Yall just be looking for shit to complain about atp
3 Likes
what no patch notes releases does to a mfers
realistically every kingdom does this and its likely gonna be added whenever kingdom alignment is supposed to come out (i forgot its changed too much)
but with the Grand Navy in place, kingdoms likely have less focus on the sea in regards to criminals and similar threats and allow the grand navy to do some of that work for them
the navy of the kingdoms still undoubtedly defend waters close to their territories (and for some kingdoms like Keraxe I imagine this would extend through most if not all of their sea depending on how much they control and their general behavior)
I imagine the farther away you go from any kingdom the more the Grand Navy starts doing that job instead
basically grand navy does criminal hunting far out into the sea so the kingdoms dont need to
2 Likes
its like the arcane UN
Yes, but it is an example of a piece of media with universally loved world building. The world of one piece is very cartoonish but everything within the world feels like it belongs together
That sounds pretty fair.
I’d imagine it’s probably unrealistic for a completely neutral faction that spans around every territory to exist and solely have the purpose to catch some criminals.
Normally the kingdoms should regulate their own territory for the unwanted.
However it would make sense considering the hierarchy in AO and the singular power a individual can get, there’d be an influx of powerful criminals and a lack of need for power in society when you could just train and get hella strong.
so in AO it’d make sense to have the GN or else it’d be pure anarchy, in a civilization/real world aspect probably not.