I’m reading all of this in the Charii5 voice, send help
“If there’s another person on this island, why didn’t he wake me up or at the very least drag me away from the shoreline?”
“Only a couple of dialogue options actually lead with the MC’s full name, so if we don’t take those, then realistically speaking, we should be nameless for most of the story.”
“Wait, so we took two rowboats to escape from being tortured before the story starts, but one of us died and we passed out? Did we pass out as soon as we made landfall? If not, how in the mother of Tartarus did Morden drag both boats to wherever we are?”
“So… you claim the MC is your friend, but you left them to sleep on the shore where they could very easily be washed away into the sea, on an island where they could very easily be murked by lightning no less, and THEN make them row on their lonesome to an island they can’t even remember the name of? If you didn’t give us our Relic before heading off, you would’ve been outed as a fraud almost immediately!”
“Also, why wasn’t our Relic taken from us while we were kidnapped? Surely that would’ve been something of interest, right?”
“OKAY, so Morden sent me to Redwake alone like an idiot and now I have to deal with more idiots leaving their entire island defenseless from the pirate faction next door? Did Hecate NOT give humanity the gift of forethought?!”
“Ignoring the story fallacies for a second… …Why should I invest my Stat Points into anything that isn’t Magic right away? Spirit doesn’t have a M1 and has to wait until Level 20 to get a supportive Rite, Weapons get their first three Skill Slots at Level 15, and Strength only gets its first Technique at the same time. The only stats that make it clear what they’re about are Spirit and Magic, but Magic’s progression is better in every way.”
“SO YOU KNEW THERE WERE PIRATES THREATENING THE ISLAND, WHY DID YOU LEAVE IT DEFENSELESS???”
“On top of that, you were out just recently, why didn’t you ask that hermit (who you know exists at the very least) about why your ships were melting on your way back to Redwake?”