Large waves are cool but i dont think that they should be able you snatch you off your ship, since the later ranges are absolutely infested with them. Its gotten so bad that seeing someone standing on a ship without holding on to an attachment almost gives me a panic attack.
Whirlpools in the dark sea are usually so rare they are barely an issue. Those gigantic ones in the later ranges look so cool
Honestly they wouldnt be an issue if they just spawned far away on the horizon
I have never ever died to them, but i think their damage could get nerfed
They are just a minor inconvinience, you can easily outrange them with culverins so i dont think they are an issue either
Yeah they are pretty cool, the only problem i have is that their average inteligence is comparable to a wooden chair. It would be nice if they were actually smart and wouldnt jump off a cliff every time
I dont mind it being rare, but please, for the love of GOD, make it so that when does actually spawn its not inside of a fucking wall 
Fighting dragons is really fun and rewarding except for that one projectile attack 
Armor breaking doesnt really do much since all attacks that break armor are easy to dodge or avoid so i dont really care
The Omen is so harmless if you dont want to fight it. Every single time i see it the omen just lets me sail away without a scratch.
The rest i have nothing to say about