I’m not having this discussion again so you won’t see me reply to you again. If you don’t like AI that’s fine but I’m going to use it anyway to add something to visually reference for people that are actually here to read my suggestion and not for AI art critics to whine about while contributing nothing. I can’t draw and don’t have artist friends. 
Lost Fighting Style Idea - Titan's Strength
https://forum.arcaneodyssey.dev/uploads/default/optimized/4X/e/2/7/e276f12a8c0786ee886411c6f5002f7ee6021c53_2_1024x1024.jpeg
effort
4.777777777777778
9
quality
4.4
10
reasonability
3.777777777777778
9
I’m done dealing with people like you two. I’ve flagged you both. Open to hearing feedback and ideas from people interested in the suggestion, not rage bait and shitposting.
ok my main critiques are above (get your head out of your ass if you actually want my opinion)
+especially on that ai slop… ai bad ooga booga but atleast u removed it from the post so props to u there
Let’s start over yeah? I’m sorry you don’t like that I try to hold myself with integrity during arguments and wasn’t appreciative of your rating of the topic being short and unhelpful to the discussion (IE my “head being up my ass”). I’m sorry we didn’t get along. You originally made the point of you thinking it couldn’t be added because you thought it wasn’t possible but I and others made some valid points explaining why it was in the way that I had described it.
Do you have any other feedback to provide in regards to the suggestion? Ideally things other than throwing around insults or commenting on the AI images that I’ve only used just to give people something to look at and get an idea of what I envision the visuals to be, as that kind of feedback isn’t helpful and just sparks drama. You have the floor, show me that you’re here to be apart of the discussion of this suggestion and not just to spark drama.
Going to drop a poll here for everyone and get people thinking about the suggestion again! Do you guys think the suggestion should stay as it is, be nerfed in some way, buffed in some way, or redesigned with the same level of power? These are the ideas people have presented so far of what could use a change (though other concerns of yours are also valid):
How should I rewrite the suggestion if at all?
- No Changes Needed
- Slight Nerf
- Slight Buff
- General Redesign
0
voters
is this the most high quality suggestion I’ve ever read…
he isn’t gonna pay cash money for a rough reference, end of conversation
once again, reference images were never required in suggestions
sorry though, I just found it annoying that people were focusing on the AI more than the suggestion
the suggestion is AI assisted. ProbableHazard was my main inspiration for my first suggestion, but I’m just disappointed. The use of AI, to me, shows carelessness regarding both his and other people’s work. (Plus yknow, the theft at play here)
3 Likes
Annoying AI Drama
The entire idea as a whole is mine from the ground up, AI didn’t touch the idea in any way other than rephrase the very last paragraph of mechanics (which I then manually touched up after) because I couldn’t phrase it very well initially while still meaning exactly the same as what I meant. You’re acting like my entire idea is bad or illegitimate because I generated some visual references, which is actually absurd. I get that you don’t like AI and the methods large corporations used to make art generation possible, but I’m not less of a person for using it.
Also I literally generated an AI ref once before for another fighting style suggestion already and nobody complained then! I didn’t need a reference but I wanted one just to have a thumbnail and give people something to look at, I don’t have any money, I generated one, and now suddenly my suggestion is worse because I generated one? Believing that is just stupid, regardless of the moral ambiguity of using AI art. I didn’t steal a damn thing. Did you force a child to make your phone for you for absolute pennies in some factory in China because you’re using it? No? There you go then. If we have to take indirect accountability for the things we use in this society we’re all going to hell before we turn 1 year old. I hate that I have to constantly talk about this crap, when what I want is for people to engage with the suggestion! The moral dilemma of using AI shouldn’t even apply until someone starts profiting off of AI generated content anyways, as that’s the only time in which it legally even counts as theft of any kind! This suggestion makes no profit for me or anyone, the content of the suggestion was entirely original, and the reference images were made from my ideas not the other way around. Also is it theft to learn how to draw by taking inspiration from other people’s art styles and pieces without paying them for every single one you look at?
Last thing promise, but calling this suggestion AI-assisted is wild considering that auto-correct is AI, which makes every suggestion AI-assisted. Those images account for such a minuscule part of the quality and content of this suggestion that it’s crazy you people are so fixated on it. Like screaming about a speck of black pepper being in your 5 Michelin star vanilla pudding.
not everyone uses autocorrect
how does ai show carelessness
some peoplejust genuinely get so butthurt over shit that doesnt matter at all
1 Like
90% of people do…
Boosting this post so people not scrolling know there’s an important poll I put up and the replies aren’t just drama. Next suggestion I do if someone starts causing drama I’m just gonna immediately ignore and flag if it’s warranted.
Change Update
The name poll seems pretty clear cut so I’ll be closing it and changing the name from Titan Strength to Titan’s Strength!
yeah im just surprised that he said that nobody doesn’t use it in the middle of an argument
The poll on whether or not it’s ancient or lost tier is a little too close for me to call it one way or other. Oh well.
I should mention this as I only realize now my phrasing could have been confusing. Very low speed relative to the average for a lost tier style would be around what iron leg has now, and for ancient would be faster than that for sure. I’d consider iron leg’s speed low for base tier.
Which balance/design changes should I make to the style? (Multiple Choice)
- Remove size scaling with total energy and leave that to strength stat allocation percentage. (Slight QoL buff and the energy drain increase will still remain but be less impactful.)
- Increase the dash distance of the style but also the cooldown. (Redesign)
- Increase maximum resistance added to techniques to 20%. (Moderate Buff)
- Keep it as is, again.
0
voters