(The positions of the images and the rows don’t matter)
I love to hear thoughts on this and your opinions on islands.
Pretty valid list
I agree
redwake and sailor’s lodge are s tier. Also Sameria > Ravenna. I’d swap fort castrum and fort talos
Gloam ruins is definitely my favorite island, somehow it’s smaller than most islands, maybe even Thorin’s refuge, but I’d say it feels at least as big as Dawn island
Erm, you forgot the Epicenter and Toymaker Island 
0/10
0 points of interest
1 featureless crater
0 ways to find reliably