I may be the guy who hates everything that people like, but I can’t help but love the current chest system. I like finding a Golden chest and opening it for 4 dope items instead of a regular chest which is just 4 galleons and sometimes a hat. It’s a good system, and it makes it feel rewarding to jump off the ship and stop everything to get a banana colored chest.
I think having them be more likely to give rare items is good, but you’re doing away with it having more rewards.