As vetex has revealed a while back there are plans/wants to make pve clans and pvp clans and simply, I don’t think the two should be a thing.
Instead clans shouldn’t force the pvp toggle instead certain activities/requirements should like force pvp toggle. A clan with a certain level of infamy should force the PvP toggle to all players within the clan, contesting/claiming/having a claimed island within that server should have all members within the clan PvP toggled. If someone is just in a clan for fun they shouldn’t be punished by others by becoming targets for PvP though like renown if you actively partake in the activities then the toggle should be forced. Separating the two could mean people who worked on island claiming now potential lose all their progress to transfer to a pve toggle but also would be unfair if someone has an island claimed that you couldn’t take it cause of the toggle.
PvP is trash, if you let me claim islands, build stuff and farm reagents without having to deal with meta sweats each time I join game I take this option
While I’m not the biggest fan of PvP though I love duels for consensual PvP. I do think claiming island and high renown is a better comprise with the PvP toggle then ANYONE in a clan.
While I agree and that would be an ideal world I don’t think vetex is willing to be rid of random PvP completely especially for clans. I just hope this would be seen as a comprise cause I don’t think clan them selves are inheritly PvP based just actives they can partake in are
He vaguely talked about the idea during his pvp toggle and lightly talks about it atleast in patreon chat and says he’s not sure yet. I think this would be an easier way to do such with similar results.
i agreed until i read the post
pve clans are just frankly baffle me
how do you go about letting people claim islands, (the main feature people want out of pve clans) while not having it interfere with pvp clans taking islands
imo vet should just put pots into frigates and the problem solves itself
Well in the post I did say in your clan has an active claim, contesting, or trying to claim an island at all within that server the clan in that server would be forced into PvP toggle until they have no claims and aren’t trying to claim. I also put if they have high infamy everyone in the clan in all servers are forced into PvP.
at that point its barely any different from a normal clan and theres barely any point in there being a difference
it would just mean half the time i see an icon above someones head i cant get infamy from them