Offering 5k galleons + clean lance of loyalty for 2 exotic fishies (by real exotic I mean a true exotic which is a Giant variant of a rare fish, not a golden uncommon)
Will give 2500 galleons for 1 true exotic fishy
I completely forgot I caught a golden basking shark yesterday and I only got 40 mins till it rots xd. IGN: The_elment
why not just cook it? it’s already the second best legendary
3 fish + marjorarm herb equals to the longest recovery time from what I’ve experimented, yes I’m gonna cook it but I’d like to have 2 other golden fish to cook it with rather than rares
giant exotics are better. 50% more duration than legendary. just a recommendation
Did not know that, thanks I’ll change the post then I 'spose
Cancelling this but I did manage to get a giant rare fish before it rotted and some other fish, was able to make this 
nice
do you remember the recipe? I could use some data to get a sense of how it’s calculated
Sure I do, I was thinking of taking a SS but I’m not sure why I didn’t, you’ll just have to trust me on it Ig
It was golden basking shark + giant sleeper shark + regular colossal squid + marjorarm herb
One of these days, I’ve got to figure out what “Fish Based Meal” counts as. It seems obvious, but I’m pretty sure I’ve had 3-fish + Marojam meal not be boosted as much as I expected.
damn, those are high duration picks. not surprised it lasts that long
Yup. One of these days I wanna make the absolute highest duration recovery 5 possible but Idk if I’ll actually go out of my way to do so.
I’m a bit mad at myself tho cuz like 5 days ago I had caught a golden eel which is (supposedly) on par with great whites and colossal squids however I forgot about it and just let it rot without cooking it, it is what it is though
tbh I prefer using Exotic Fish so that it doesn’t feel like I wasted my Sun Caroway. Rec V + Fortified 2 is really pretty cool
@Ravencliffe I could probably just test this myself but lazy, do you know if using the same fish twice or 3 times affects a meals duration? If it does then the absolute longest recovery 5 meal would be golden colossal squid/golden giant eel + giant great white + giant basking shark or anything of equal hunger + marjoram, if it doesn’t then could just use 2 or 3 of the same fish
Yea fair, I’m not really a fan of using higher tier leg fish to make fortified or agile or energizing etc meals, only with lower tiers
giant eel is dogwater. 15m 16s for golden. also I haven’t reached that far yet, but I assume fish do have diminishing returns but idk about different sizes
if you want the absolute longest, given that different sizes don’t affect duration, it’d be Golden Colossal Squid, Golden Basking Shark, Colossal Squid, Giant Basking Shark
otherwise, it’d be Golden Colossal Squid, Giant Basking Shark, Giant Sleeper Shark, Giant Great White Shark
You sure golden eel is bad? I mean I assumed a fishies hunger giving was based off its value not how visually big it is
The combos you listed seem weird if the fishes hunger is based off their value but I guess if its based off visuals it could be true?
why 2 goldens if giants give more, very confused
There’s a chart of what each fish is worth hunger-wise.
look at my database to understand. I have almost every single fish stats listed. surprised you haven’t used it as a reference yet, given how active you are here
also do you get buyers for your fishes? they look overpriced as hell to me, given some of their stats
Very interesting
I never really liked the formatting of it was honestly a big turn off for me, and I mainly only saw it in the early stages so I found it kinda useless at the time, it’s a lot more useful now with more info, I also see some fishies aren’t listed there so if I get them I’ll let u know their stats
I don’t sell fish unless you mean my other marketplace post, if so, no I didn’t get any, the pricing was quite similar to another guys pricing who supposedly sold them, don’t think either of us knew how their recovery duration worked though nor do most people (unless I’m the only one who was oblivious)