Well then it’s just gonna gradually become worse, which is almost as bad as it being situationally ineffective.
Instead of only working on some targets, it only works sometimes on every target.
so basically
guilty gear guts mechanic
Exactly
It’s gradually becomes worse
That’s the entire point/gimmick of ap that I’m trying to introduce
It’s much more mathematical and much less ‘oh god I hope they run 3k hp or else I’m screwed’
Makes it less dependent on external factors
I like my idea, idk.
Your idea or mine, the point is
We both agree that ap needs a rework
I just think it’s hardly an improvement if it still doesn’t work 50% of the time.
That’s probably the stupidest idea i’ve ever heard, %maxhp damage will NEVER be a good idea
He said current 
Max Hp % is Stock’s idea
still stupid
AP needs to be killed, even if you rework it its a weird power 2, its pointless, make a new stat
can we overtune ap again i hate defense
Are you stupid
Stock is the one with the max hp idea
I’m the one with the current hp idea
I feel like that if we did the max hp then it’s scaling has to be nerfed to the ground
AP has potential, its execution was just poorly done
What does this mean
i think ap should be made broken again because i hate defense and tanky builds in general
it would be awesome and cool
I mean
If you refer to this post as making it broken… sure?
Honestly, I’m not trying to make it broken
Just trying to make the difference between high def and low def enemy less
(Especially since right now ap depends on your enemy’s stats which ARE DIFFERENT FOR EACH PLAYER)
Also didn’t they nerf def by 18.18%
However if you’re just asking for a broken stat, I’m sorry but I can’t deliver, as I only want to balance out a poorly-executed stat
i think they did? doesnt change much regardless, i still hate fighting tanky builds
wasnt referring to anything in particular i just wanted an excuse to hate on tanky builds
and as i said current hp is equally sutpid if you could read
Oh I’m sorry
May I trouble you to atleast tell me why you think it’s a terrible idea?
And if so, could you come up with a better idea?
But alright
I have an alternative
Which is this: