Has the delete badge for another headless bug ever worked?

[BBII]

Halloween headless item bug?

Weird, while on this topic you can delete your Halloween badge and collect another Halloween item and get 2 headless heads

Headless Horseman Head

So the Halloween event has been present for many time now and I did the event on my main file and got the headless horseman head. I did the event on my second file and did not get the headless horseman head, so I am asking is the item restricted to 1 per player?

I looked into a bit more, and I found a couple posts suggesting that just obtaining a single more Halloween item will grant an additional headless after deleting the badge on another save, but I found another post contradicting that

So whats headless head worth

It’s not duping, you need to earn the badge every time. So you would just have to get all the Halloween items on another file to get another headless. It’s fair game, you earned another headless, just like you would on an alt account.

After 10-15 minutes of looking through old posts, I’m not so sure myself, but you should likely ask one of the people who used that method for a more definitive answer