Either that, or just make it fully class based, so for conjurer, they get 50% weapon based stuff, 50% mage, warlocks, 50% mage, 50% berserker items, and etc. That would honestly be really nice.
A proposal for reworking the most tedious feature of AO: Modifiers
effort
4.477272727272728
44
quality
4.553191489361702
47
reasonability
4.464285714285714
56
lower tier treasure spots like the first for an uncommon
actually atp make it so chest loot is based on the sea and chest type, like in bronze sea normal chests are level 0-50, silver chests are 50-100, gold chests are 100-150
nimbus normal chests are 100-150, silver 150-200, gold 200-250, etc etc
1 Like
That is also a sick idea actually, would make gold chests even MORE worth-while to collect.
yeah but it would still be capped at your level (no level 250 items at level 140 guys 
)
That is already how it works, so just adding this would add to it, and its a nice QOL feature.
Did I miss another argument
Bruh why 1 star effort
Even if you think the suggestion is dogshit he clearly put effort into it
I never understand why people give false ratings for stuff like effort, especially cuz you gave a 3 star for everything else
read
Actually yeah that would fix the issues
And @anon8505296 would lose their reason to complain
That may be true
However I’m still keeping my rating
It’s not about the rating, it’s about making sure you don’t have the grievance.
Although that’s awfully pretentious of you still
it’s ok they’re a redditor just ignore em
It’s not a superiority complex when you are superior
Yeah that’s appropriate here
I’m not telling you which though (cuz it’s both 
)
RB1 alt incoming
I think if this idea was to go through, a downside would be the loss of the sense of there being “second place” prizes. For example, say I’m digging up blasted. I might not get a power or arcanium, but maybe I’ll get sorcerer gear, or some pauldrons. Perhaps I’ll get something that just looks cool, like blasted steel. After this is implemented, the only thing worth my attention would be “Blasted Essence”.
Then there’s the trade factor to consider. I’m not talking about value, but rather what people will look for. Would you look through someone’s equipment items to see if they have the modified item you want, or would you look for “* Essence” and call it a day? I liked searching through inventories, seeing if I could find what I am looking for, and trying to make a deal.
In addition, with the new rewards from treasure charts in the next update, there will be more people doing treasure charts, which means more supply, which means the modified items will be more available without the need for modifier essences.
I don’t think this idea would ruin the game, or even be a net decrease in quality seeing how some feel about it, but I think there would be some trade-offs, and I wouldn’t want to make that trade.
Then again, if we can throw tradeable quest items into the deal, then I’d be happy. I could get myself a full set of modified banana backpacks.
True
To be honest if they did something like making modifiers like this, but also introduced a new set of tradeoff modifiers like Atlantean which can ONLY be found at their respective locations, that would probably be good for the game. The “forgotten” stat from the false hydra suggestion could be one, drawback another, and we could remove Atlantean essence so pre-Atlantean items are allowed (and this would probably BOOST the economy by making Atlantean boss gear extremely valuable.)